Overleaf/services/project-history/test/unit/js/SyncManager/SyncManagerTests.js

import sinon from 'sinon'
import { expect } from 'chai'
import mongodb from 'mongodb-legacy'
import tk from 'timekeeper'
import {
  File,
  Comment,
  TrackedChange,
  Range,
  TrackingProps,
} from 'overleaf-editor-core'
import { UnprocessableError } from 'overleaf-editor-core/lib/errors.js'
import { strict as esmock } from 'esmock'
import { FileContentEmptyError } from '../../../../app/js/Errors.js'
const { ObjectId } = mongodb

const MODULE_PATH = '../../../../app/js/SyncManager.js'
const TIMESTAMP = new Date().toISOString()
const USER_ID = 'user-id'

function resyncProjectStructureUpdate(docs, files) {
  return {
    resyncProjectStructure: { docs, files },

    meta: {
      ts: TIMESTAMP,
    },
  }
}

function docContentSyncUpdate(
  doc,
  content,
  ranges = {},
  resolvedCommentIds = []
) {
  return {
    path: doc.path,
    doc: doc.doc,

    resyncDocContent: {
      content,
      ranges,
      resolvedCommentIds,
    },

    meta: {
      ts: TIMESTAMP,
    },
  }
}

function makeComment(commentId, pos, text) {
  return {
    id: commentId,
    op: { p: pos, c: text, t: commentId },
    metadata: {
      user_id: USER_ID,
      ts: TIMESTAMP,
    },
  }
}

function makeTrackedChange(id, op) {
  return {
    id,
    op,
    metadata: { user_id: USER_ID, ts: TIMESTAMP },
  }
}

describe('SyncManager', function () {
  beforeEach(async function () {
    this.now = new Date()
    tk.freeze(this.now)
    this.projectId = new ObjectId().toString()
    this.historyId = 'mock-overleaf-id'
    this.syncState = { origin: { kind: 'history-resync' } }
    this.db = {
      projectHistorySyncState: {
        findOne: sinon.stub().resolves(this.syncState),
        updateOne: sinon.stub().resolves(),
      },
      projects: {
        updateOne: sinon.stub().resolves(),
      },
    }
    this.extendLock = sinon.stub().resolves()

    this.LockManager = {
      promises: {
        runWithLock: sinon.stub().callsFake(async (key, runner) => {
          await runner(this.extendLock)
        }),
      },
    }

    this.UpdateCompressor = {
      diffAsShareJsOps: sinon.stub().returns([]),
    }

    this.UpdateTranslator = {
      isTextUpdate: sinon.stub(),
      _convertPathname: sinon.stub(),
    }

    this.WebApiManager = {
      promises: {
        getHistoryId: sinon.stub(),
        requestResync: sinon.stub().resolves(),
      },
    }
    this.WebApiManager.promises.getHistoryId
      .withArgs(this.projectId)
      .resolves(this.historyId)

    this.ErrorRecorder = {
      promises: {
        record: sinon.stub().resolves(),
        recordSyncStart: sinon.stub().resolves(),
      },
    }

    this.RedisManager = {}

    this.SnapshotManager = {
      promises: {
        getLatestSnapshotFilesForChunk: sinon.stub(),
      },
    }

    this.HistoryStoreManager = {
      getBlobStore: sinon.stub(),
      _getBlobHashFromString: sinon.stub().returns('random-hash'),
    }

    this.HashManager = {
      _getBlobHashFromString: sinon.stub(),
    }

    this.Metrics = { inc: sinon.stub() }

    this.Settings = {
      redis: {
        lock: {
          key_schema: {
            projectHistoryLock({ project_id: projectId }) {
              return `ProjectHistoryLock:${projectId}`
            },
          },
        },
      },
    }

    this.SyncManager = await esmock(
      MODULE_PATH,
      {
        '../../../../app/js/LockManager.js': this.LockManager,
        '../../../../app/js/UpdateCompressor.js': this.UpdateCompressor,
        '../../../../app/js/UpdateTranslator.js': this.UpdateTranslator,
        '../../../../app/js/mongodb.js': { ObjectId, db: this.db },
        '../../../../app/js/WebApiManager.js': this.WebApiManager,
        '../../../../app/js/ErrorRecorder.js': this.ErrorRecorder,
        '../../../../app/js/RedisManager.js': this.RedisManager,
        '../../../../app/js/SnapshotManager.js': this.SnapshotManager,
        '../../../../app/js/HistoryStoreManager.js': this.HistoryStoreManager,
        '../../../../app/js/HashManager.js': this.HashManager,
        '@overleaf/metrics': this.Metrics,
        '@overleaf/settings': this.Settings,
      },
      {
        'overleaf-editor-core/lib/errors.js':
          await import('overleaf-editor-core/lib/errors.js'),
        '../../../../app/js/Errors.js':
          await import('../../../../app/js/Errors.js'),
      }
    )
  })

  afterEach(function () {
    tk.reset()
  })

  describe('startResync', function () {
    describe('if a sync is not in progress', function () {
      beforeEach(async function () {
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves({})
        await this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
      })

      it('takes the project lock', function () {
        expect(this.LockManager.promises.runWithLock).to.have.been.calledWith(
          `ProjectHistoryLock:${this.projectId}`
        )
      })

      it('gets the sync state from mongo', function () {
        expect(this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) }
        )
      })

      it('requests a resync from web', function () {
        expect(
          this.WebApiManager.promises.requestResync
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(this.projectId)
      })

      it('sets the sync state in mongo and prevents it expiring', function () {
        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          {
            project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId),
          },
          sinon.match({
            $set: sinon.match({
              resyncProjectStructure: true,
              resyncDocContents: [],
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            }),
            $currentDate: { lastUpdated: true },
            $inc: { resyncCount: 1 },
            $unset: { expiresAt: true },
          }),
          {
            upsert: true,
          }
        )
      })
    })

    describe('if project structure sync is in progress', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        const syncState = {
          resyncProjectStructure: true,
          resyncPendingSince: new Date(),
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('returns an error if already syncing', async function () {
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        ).to.be.rejectedWith('sync ongoing')
      })
    })

    describe('if doc content sync in is progress', function () {
      beforeEach(async function () {
        const syncState = {
          resyncDocContents: ['/foo.tex'],
          resyncPendingSince: new Date(),
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('returns an error if already syncing', async function () {
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        ).to.be.rejectedWith('sync ongoing')
      })
    })

    describe('if sync is stuck (no resyncPendingSince — legacy state)', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        const syncState = { resyncDocContents: ['/foo.tex'] }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('records the stuck clear, does not delete state, and starts a new resync', async function () {
        await this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) },
          sinon.match({
            $inc: { stuckClearCount: 1 },
            $unset: { resyncPendingSince: 1 },
          })
        )
        expect(this.WebApiManager.promises.requestResync.calledOnce).to.be.true
        expect(
          this.Metrics.inc.calledWith('project_history_sync_stuck_cleared')
        ).to.be.true
      })
    })

    describe('if sync is stuck (resyncPendingSince older than timeout)', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        const fiveHoursAgo = new Date(Date.now() - 5 * 60 * 60 * 1000)
        const syncState = {
          resyncDocContents: ['/foo.tex'],
          resyncPendingSince: fiveHoursAgo,
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('records the stuck clear and starts a new resync', async function () {
        await this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) },
          sinon.match({
            $inc: { stuckClearCount: 1 },
            $unset: { resyncPendingSince: 1 },
          })
        )
        expect(this.WebApiManager.promises.requestResync.calledOnce).to.be.true
      })
    })

    describe('if sync is not stuck (resyncPendingSince within timeout)', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        const threeHoursAgo = new Date(Date.now() - 3 * 60 * 60 * 1000)
        const syncState = {
          resyncDocContents: ['/foo.tex'],
          resyncPendingSince: threeHoursAgo,
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('throws sync ongoing and does not clear', async function () {
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        ).to.be.rejectedWith('sync ongoing')
        expect(
          this.Metrics.inc.calledWith('project_history_sync_stuck_cleared')
        ).to.be.false
        expect(
          this.Metrics.inc.calledWith('project_history_sync_stuck_permanent')
        ).to.be.false
      })
    })

    describe('if sync is permanently stuck (exceeded retry limit)', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        const syncState = {
          resyncDocContents: ['/foo.tex'],
          stuckClearCount: 5,
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('throws permanently stuck, emits metric, and records the attempt', async function () {
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        ).to.be.rejectedWith('sync permanently stuck')
        expect(
          this.Metrics.inc.calledWith('project_history_sync_stuck_permanent')
        ).to.be.true
        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) },
          sinon.match({ $inc: { stuckClearCount: 1 } })
        )
      })

      it('does not attempt a resync', async function () {
        try {
          await this.SyncManager.promises.startResync(this.projectId)
        } catch (e) {
          // expected
        }
        expect(this.WebApiManager.promises.requestResync.called).to.be.false
      })
    })
  })

  describe('setResyncState', function () {
    describe('when the sync is starting', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        this.syncState = {
          toRaw() {
            return {
              resyncProjectStructure: true,
              resyncDocContents: [],
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            }
          },
          isSyncOngoing: sinon.stub().returns(true),
        }
      })

      it('sets the sync state in mongo and prevents it expiring', async function () {
        // SyncState is a private class of SyncManager
        // we know the interface however:
        await this.SyncManager.promises.setResyncState(
          this.projectId,
          this.syncState
        )

        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) },
          sinon.match({
            $set: sinon.match({
              resyncProjectStructure: true,
              resyncDocContents: [],
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            }),
            $currentDate: { lastUpdated: true },
            $inc: { resyncCount: 1 },
            $unset: { expiresAt: true },
          }),
          { upsert: true }
        )
      })
    })

    describe('when the sync is ending', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        this.syncState = {
          toRaw() {
            return {
              resyncProjectStructure: false,
              resyncDocContents: [],
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            }
          },
          isSyncOngoing: sinon.stub().returns(false),
        }
      })

      it('sets the sync state entry in mongo to expire and clears stuck fields', async function () {
        await this.SyncManager.promises.setResyncState(
          this.projectId,
          this.syncState
        )

        expect(
          this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne
        ).to.have.been.calledWith(
          { project_id: new ObjectId(this.projectId) },
          sinon.match({
            $set: {
              resyncProjectStructure: false,
              resyncDocContents: [],
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
              expiresAt: new Date(this.now.getTime() + 90 * 24 * 3600 * 1000),
            },
            $currentDate: { lastUpdated: true },
            $unset: {
              resyncPendingSince: 1,
              stuckClearCount: 1,
              lastStuckClearAt: 1,
              lastStuckDocPaths: 1,
            },
          }),
          { upsert: true }
        )
      })
    })

    describe('when the new sync state is null', function () {
      it('does not update the sync state in mongo', async function () {
        // SyncState is a private class of SyncManager
        // we know the interface however:
        await this.SyncManager.promises.setResyncState(this.projectId, null)
        expect(this.db.projectHistorySyncState.updateOne).to.not.have.been
          .called
      })
    })
  })

  describe('skipUpdatesDuringSync', function () {
    describe('if a sync is not in progress', function () {
      beforeEach(async function () {
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves({})
        this.updates = ['some', 'mock', 'updates']
        this.result = await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
          this.projectId,
          this.updates
        )
      })

      it('returns all updates', function () {
        expect(this.result.updates).to.deep.equal(this.updates)
      })

      it('should not return any newSyncState', function () {
        expect(this.result.syncState).to.be.null
      })
    })

    describe('if a sync in is progress', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        this.renameUpdate = {
          pathname: 'old.tex',
          newPathname: 'new.tex',
        }
        this.projectStructureSyncUpdate = {
          resyncProjectStructure: {
            docs: [{ path: 'new.tex' }],
            files: [],
          },
        }
        this.textUpdate = {
          doc: new ObjectId(),
          op: [{ i: 'a', p: 4 }],
          meta: {
            pathname: 'new.tex',
            doc_length: 4,
          },
        }
        this.docContentSyncUpdate = {
          path: 'new.tex',
          resyncDocContent: {
            content: 'a',
          },
        }
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate
          .withArgs(this.renameUpdate)
          .returns(false)
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate
          .withArgs(this.projectStructureSyncUpdate)
          .returns(false)
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate
          .withArgs(this.docContentSyncUpdate)
          .returns(false)
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate
          .withArgs(this.textUpdate)
          .returns(true)

        const syncState = {
          resyncProjectStructure: true,
          resyncDocContents: [],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(syncState)
      })

      it('remove updates before a project structure sync update', async function () {
        const updates = [
          this.renameUpdate,
          this.textUpdate,
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
        ]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([this.projectStructureSyncUpdate])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: ['new.tex'],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })

      it('records docs to resync when resyncProjectStructureOnly=true is not set', async function () {
        const updates = [this.projectStructureSyncUpdate]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([this.projectStructureSyncUpdate])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: ['new.tex'],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })

      it('records no docs to resync with resyncProjectStructureOnly=true', async function () {
        this.projectStructureSyncUpdate.resyncProjectStructureOnly = true
        const updates = [this.projectStructureSyncUpdate]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([this.projectStructureSyncUpdate])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: [],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })

      it('allow project structure updates after project structure sync update', async function () {
        const updates = [this.projectStructureSyncUpdate, this.renameUpdate]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
          this.renameUpdate,
        ])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: ['new.tex'],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })

      it('remove text updates for a doc before doc sync update', async function () {
        const updates = [
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
          this.textUpdate,
          this.docContentSyncUpdate,
        ]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
          this.docContentSyncUpdate,
        ])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: [],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })

      it('allow text updates for a doc after doc sync update', async function () {
        const updates = [
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
          this.docContentSyncUpdate,
          this.textUpdate,
        ]
        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            updates
          )

        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          this.projectStructureSyncUpdate,
          this.docContentSyncUpdate,
          this.textUpdate,
        ])
        expect(syncState.toRaw()).to.deep.equal({
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: [],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
          hardResync: false,
          recoverCorruptedFiles: false,
        })
      })
    })
  })

  describe('expandSyncUpdates', function () {
    beforeEach(function () {
      this.persistedDoc = {
        doc: 'doc-id',
        path: 'main.tex',
      }
      this.persistedDocContent = 'the quick brown fox jumps over the lazy dog'
      this.persistedFile = {
        file: 'file-id',
        path: '1.png',
        _hash: 'abcde',
      }
      this.loadedSnapshotDoc = File.fromString(this.persistedDocContent)
      this.mostRecentChunk = 'fake chunk'
      this.fileMap = {
        'main.tex': {
          isEditable: sinon.stub().returns(true),
          getContent: sinon.stub().returns(null),
          getHash: sinon.stub().returns(null),
          load: sinon.stub().resolves(this.loadedSnapshotDoc),
          getMetadata: sinon.stub().returns({}),
        },
        '1.png': {
          isEditable: sinon.stub().returns(false),
          data: { hash: this.persistedFile._hash },
          getMetadata: sinon.stub().returns({}),
        },
      }
      this.UpdateTranslator._convertPathname
        .withArgs('main.tex')
        .returns('main.tex')
      this.UpdateTranslator._convertPathname
        .withArgs('/main.tex')
        .returns('main.tex')
      this.UpdateTranslator._convertPathname
        .withArgs('another.tex')
        .returns('another.tex')
      this.UpdateTranslator._convertPathname.withArgs('1.png').returns('1.png')
      this.UpdateTranslator._convertPathname.withArgs('2.png').returns('2.png')
      this.SnapshotManager.promises.getLatestSnapshotFilesForChunk.resolves(
        this.fileMap
      )
    })

    it('returns updates if no sync updates are queued', async function () {
      const updates = ['some', 'mock', 'updates']
      const expandedUpdates = await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
        this.projectId,
        this.historyId,
        this.mostRecentChunk,
        updates,
        this.extendLock
      )

      expect(expandedUpdates).to.equal(updates)
      expect(this.SnapshotManager.promises.getLatestSnapshotFilesForChunk).to
        .not.have.been.called
      expect(this.extendLock).to.not.have.been.called
    })

    describe('expanding project structure sync updates', function () {
      it('queues nothing for expected docs and files', async function () {
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues file removes for unexpected files', async function () {
        const updates = [resyncProjectStructureUpdate([this.persistedDoc], [])]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: this.persistedFile.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues doc removes for unexpected docs', async function () {
        const updates = [resyncProjectStructureUpdate([], [this.persistedFile])]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues file additions for missing regular files', async function () {
        const newFile = {
          path: '2.png',
          file: {},
          url: 'filestore/2.png',
          _hash: 'hash-42',
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile, newFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: newFile.path,
            file: newFile.file,
            url: newFile.url,
            hash: 'hash-42',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues file additions for missing regular files w/o url', async function () {
        const newFile = {
          path: '2.png',
          file: {},
          _hash: 'hash-42',
          createdBlob: true,
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile, newFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: newFile.path,
            file: newFile.file,
            hash: 'hash-42',
            createdBlob: true,
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues file additions for missing linked files', async function () {
        const newFile = {
          path: '2.png',
          file: {},
          url: 'filestore/2.png',
          metadata: {
            importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
            provider: 'references-provider',
          },
          _hash: 'hash-42',
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile, newFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: newFile.path,
            file: newFile.file,
            url: newFile.url,
            hash: 'hash-42',
            metadata: {
              importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
              provider: 'references-provider',
            },
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues blank doc additions for missing docs', async function () {
        const newDoc = {
          path: 'another.tex',
          doc: new ObjectId().toString(),
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc, newDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: newDoc.path,
            doc: newDoc.doc,
            docLines: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('removes and re-adds files if whether they are binary differs', async function () {
        const fileWichWasADoc = {
          path: this.persistedDoc.path,
          url: 'filestore/2.png',
          _hash: 'other-hash',
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [],
            [fileWichWasADoc, this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: fileWichWasADoc.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            pathname: fileWichWasADoc.path,
            file: fileWichWasADoc.file,
            url: fileWichWasADoc.url,
            hash: 'other-hash',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('removes and re-adds linked-files if their binary state differs', async function () {
        const fileWhichWasADoc = {
          path: this.persistedDoc.path,
          url: 'filestore/references.txt',
          _hash: 'other-hash',
          metadata: {
            importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
            provider: 'references-provider',
          },
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [],
            [fileWhichWasADoc, this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: fileWhichWasADoc.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            pathname: fileWhichWasADoc.path,
            file: fileWhichWasADoc.file,
            url: fileWhichWasADoc.url,
            hash: 'other-hash',
            metadata: {
              importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
              provider: 'references-provider',
            },
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('add linked file data with same hash', async function () {
        const nowLinkedFile = {
          path: this.persistedFile.path,
          url: 'filestore/1.png',
          _hash: this.persistedFile._hash,
          metadata: {
            importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
            provider: 'image-provider',
          },
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate([this.persistedDoc], [nowLinkedFile]),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: nowLinkedFile.path,
            metadata: {
              importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
              provider: 'image-provider',
            },
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('updates linked file data when hash remains the same', async function () {
        this.fileMap[this.persistedFile.path].getMetadata.returns({
          importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
          provider: 'image-provider',
        })
        const updatedLinkedFile = {
          path: this.persistedFile.path,
          url: 'filestore/1.png',
          _hash: this.persistedFile._hash,
          metadata: {
            importedAt: '2024-07-31T00:00:00.000Z',
            provider: 'image-provider',
          },
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [updatedLinkedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: updatedLinkedFile.path,
            metadata: {
              importedAt: '2024-07-31T00:00:00.000Z',
              provider: 'image-provider',
            },
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('remove linked file data', async function () {
        this.fileMap[this.persistedFile.path].getMetadata.returns({
          importedAt: '2024-07-30T09:14:45.928Z',
          provider: 'image-provider',
        })

        const noLongerLinkedFile = {
          path: this.persistedFile.path,
          url: 'filestore/1.png',
          _hash: this.persistedFile._hash,
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [noLongerLinkedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: noLongerLinkedFile.path,
            metadata: {},
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it("does not remove and re-add files if the expected file doesn't have a hash", async function () {
        const fileWichWasADoc = {
          path: this.persistedDoc.path,
          url: 'filestore/2.png',
        }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [],
            [fileWichWasADoc, this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('does not remove and re-add editable files if there is a binary file with same hash', async function () {
        const binaryFile = {
          file: Object().toString(),
          // The paths in the resyncProjectStructureUpdate must have a leading slash ('/')
          // The other unit tests in this file are incorrectly missing the leading slash.
          // The leading slash is present in web where the paths are created with
          // ProjectEntityHandler.getAllEntitiesFromProject in ProjectEntityUpdateHandler.resyncProjectHistory.
          path: '/' + this.persistedDoc.path,
          url: 'filestore/12345',
          _hash: 'abcdef',
        }
        this.fileMap['main.tex'].data = { hash: 'abcdef' }

        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate([], [binaryFile, this.persistedFile]),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('removes and re-adds binary files if they do not have same hash', async function () {
        const persistedFileWithNewContent = {
          _hash: 'anotherhashvalue',
          hello: 'world',
          path: '1.png',
          url: 'filestore-new-url',
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [persistedFileWithNewContent]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: persistedFileWithNewContent.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            pathname: persistedFileWithNewContent.path,
            file: persistedFileWithNewContent.file,
            url: persistedFileWithNewContent.url,
            hash: 'anotherhashvalue',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('removes and re-adds binary files w/o url if they do not have same hash', async function () {
        const persistedFileWithNewContent = {
          _hash: 'anotherhashvalue',
          hello: 'world',
          path: '1.png',
          createdBlob: true,
        }
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [persistedFileWithNewContent]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: persistedFileWithNewContent.path,
            new_pathname: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            pathname: persistedFileWithNewContent.path,
            file: persistedFileWithNewContent.file,
            hash: 'anotherhashvalue',
            createdBlob: true,
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('preserves other updates', async function () {
        const update = { mock: 'update' }
        const updates = [
          update,
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([update])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })
    })

    describe('expanding doc contents sync updates', function () {
      it('returns errors from diffAsShareJsOps', async function () {
        const diffError = new Error('test')
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.throws(diffError)
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent),
        ]
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        ).to.be.rejectedWith(diffError)
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('handles an update for a file that is missing from the snapshot', async function () {
        const updates = [docContentSyncUpdate('not-in-snapshot.txt', 'test')]
        await expect(
          this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        ).to.be.rejectedWith('unrecognised file: not in snapshot')
      })

      it('queues nothing for in docs whose contents is in sync', async function () {
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent),
        ]
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([])
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues text updates for docs whose contents is out of sync', async function () {
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            'the fox jumps over the lazy dog'
          ),
        ]
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([
          { d: 'quick brown ', p: 4 },
        ])
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [{ d: 'quick brown ', p: 4 }],
            meta: {
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('queues text updates for docs created by project structure sync', async function () {
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([{ i: 'a', p: 0 }])
        const newDoc = {
          path: 'another.tex',
          doc: new ObjectId().toString(),
        }
        const newDocContent = 'a'
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc, newDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(newDoc, newDocContent),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: newDoc.path,
            doc: newDoc.doc,
            docLines: '',
            meta: {
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            doc: newDoc.doc,
            op: [{ i: 'a', p: 0 }],
            meta: {
              pathname: newDoc.path,
              doc_length: 0,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('skips text updates for docs when hashes match', async function () {
        this.fileMap['main.tex'].getHash.returns('special-hash')
        this.HashManager._getBlobHashFromString.returns('special-hash')
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, 'hello'),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      it('computes text updates for docs when hashes differ', async function () {
        this.fileMap['main.tex'].getHash.returns('first-hash')
        this.HashManager._getBlobHashFromString.returns('second-hash')
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([
          { i: 'test diff', p: 0 },
        ])
        const updates = [
          resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
            [this.persistedDoc],
            [this.persistedFile]
          ),
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, 'hello'),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [{ i: 'test diff', p: 0 }],
            meta: {
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
        expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
      })

      describe('for docs whose contents is out of sync', function () {
        beforeEach(async function () {
          const updates = [
            resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
              [this.persistedDoc],
              [this.persistedFile]
            ),
            docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, 'the quick brown fox'),
          ]
          this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([
            { d: ' jumps over the lazy dog', p: 19 },
          ])
          this.expandedUpdates =
            await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
              this.projectId,
              this.historyId,
              this.mostRecentChunk,
              updates,
              this.extendLock
            )
        })

        it('loads content from the history service when needed', function () {
          expect(this.expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
            {
              doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
              op: [{ d: ' jumps over the lazy dog', p: 19 }],
              meta: {
                pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
                doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
                resync: true,
                ts: TIMESTAMP,
                origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
              },
            },
          ])
          expect(this.extendLock).to.have.been.called
        })
      })

      describe('when the blob content is corrupted during hard resync', function () {
        describe('and the recoverCorruptedFiles flag is true', function () {
          beforeEach(function () {
            this.syncState.recoverCorruptedFiles = true
          })

          async function assertRecovery(ctx, err) {
            ctx.fileMap['main.tex'].load.rejects(err)
            const updates = [
              resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
                [ctx.persistedDoc],
                [ctx.persistedFile]
              ),
              docContentSyncUpdate(ctx.persistedDoc, ctx.persistedDocContent),
            ]
            const expandedUpdates =
              await ctx.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
                ctx.projectId,
                ctx.historyId,
                ctx.mostRecentChunk,
                updates,
                ctx.extendLock
              )
            expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
              {
                pathname: 'main.tex',
                new_pathname: '',
                meta: {
                  resync: true,
                  origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
                  ts: TIMESTAMP,
                },
              },
              {
                pathname: 'main.tex',
                doc: ctx.persistedDoc.doc,
                docLines: ctx.persistedDocContent,
                meta: {
                  resync: true,
                  origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
                  ts: TIMESTAMP,
                },
              },
            ])
          }

          it('queues REMOVE + ADD for UnprocessableError', async function () {
            await assertRecovery(this, new UnprocessableError('apply failed'))
          })

          it('queues REMOVE + ADD for SyntaxError', async function () {
            await assertRecovery(this, new SyntaxError('bad JSON'))
          })

          it('queues REMOVE + ADD for FileContentEmptyError', async function () {
            await assertRecovery(
              this,
              new FileContentEmptyError('null content')
            )
          })

          it('propagates non-corruption errors during hard resync', async function () {
            this.fileMap['main.tex'].load.rejects(
              new Error('connection timeout')
            )
            const updates = [
              resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
                [this.persistedDoc],
                [this.persistedFile]
              ),
              docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent),
            ]
            await expect(
              this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
                this.projectId,
                this.historyId,
                this.mostRecentChunk,
                updates,
                this.extendLock
              )
            ).to.be.rejectedWith('connection timeout')
          })
        })

        describe('and the recoverCorruptedFiles flag is false', function () {
          it('propagates corruption errors', async function () {
            this.syncState.recoverCorruptedFiles = false
            this.fileMap['main.tex'].load.rejects(
              new UnprocessableError('apply failed')
            )
            const updates = [
              resyncProjectStructureUpdate(
                [this.persistedDoc],
                [this.persistedFile]
              ),
              docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent),
            ]
            await expect(
              this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
                this.projectId,
                this.historyId,
                this.mostRecentChunk,
                updates,
                this.extendLock
              )
            ).to.be.rejectedWith('apply failed')
          })
        })
      })
    })

    describe('syncing comments', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc
          .getComments()
          .add(new Comment('comment1', [new Range(4, 5)]))
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc
          .getComments()
          .add(new Comment('comment2', [new Range(10, 5)], true))
        this.comments = [
          makeComment('comment1', 4, 'quick'),
          makeComment('comment2', 10, 'brown'),
        ]
        this.resolvedCommentIds = ['comment2']
      })

      it('does nothing if comments have not changed', async function () {
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
      })

      it('adds missing comments', async function () {
        this.comments.push(makeComment('comment3', 20, 'jumps'))
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              {
                c: 'jumps',
                p: 20,
                t: 'comment3',
                resolved: false,
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('deletes extra comments', async function () {
        this.comments.splice(0, 1)
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
            deleteComment: 'comment1',
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('updates comments when ranges differ', async function () {
        this.comments[1] = makeComment('comment2', 16, 'fox')
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: 'doc-id',
            op: [
              {
                c: 'fox',
                p: 16,
                t: 'comment2',
                resolved: true,
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('sets the resolved state when it differs', async function () {
        this.resolvedCommentIds = ['comment1']
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.have.deep.members([
          {
            pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
            commentId: 'comment1',
            resolved: true,
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
            },
          },
          {
            pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
            commentId: 'comment2',
            resolved: false,
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('treats zero length comments as detached comments', async function () {
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc.getComments().add(new Comment('comment1', []))
        this.comments = [
          makeComment('comment1', 16, ''),
          makeComment('comment2', 10, 'brown'),
        ]
        this.resolvedCommentIds = ['comment2']

        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            this.persistedDocContent,
            {
              comments: this.comments,
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]

        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
      })

      it('adjusts comment positions when the underlying text has changed', async function () {
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            'quick brown fox',
            {
              comments: [
                makeComment('comment1', 0, 'quick'),
                makeComment('comment2', 12, 'fox'),
              ],
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([
          { d: 'the ', p: 0 },
          { d: ' jumps over the lazy dog', p: 15 },
        ])
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              { d: 'the ', p: 0 },
              { d: ' jumps over the lazy dog', p: 15 },
            ],
            meta: {
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              {
                c: 'fox',
                p: 12,
                t: 'comment2',
                resolved: true,
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              doc_length: 'quick brown fox'.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })
    })

    describe('syncing tracked changes', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc.getTrackedChanges().add(
          new TrackedChange(
            new Range(4, 6),
            TrackingProps.fromRaw({
              type: 'delete',
              userId: USER_ID,
              ts: new Date(TIMESTAMP).toISOString(),
            })
          )
        )
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc.getTrackedChanges().add(
          new TrackedChange(
            new Range(10, 6),
            TrackingProps.fromRaw({
              type: 'insert',
              userId: USER_ID,
              ts: new Date(TIMESTAMP).toISOString(),
            })
          )
        )
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc.getTrackedChanges().add(
          new TrackedChange(
            new Range(20, 6),
            TrackingProps.fromRaw({
              type: 'delete',
              userId: USER_ID,
              ts: new Date(TIMESTAMP).toISOString(),
            })
          )
        )
        this.loadedSnapshotDoc.getTrackedChanges().add(
          new TrackedChange(
            new Range(40, 3),
            TrackingProps.fromRaw({
              type: 'insert',
              userId: USER_ID,
              ts: new Date(TIMESTAMP).toISOString(),
            })
          )
        )
        this.changes = [
          makeTrackedChange('td1', { p: 4, d: 'quick ' }),
          makeTrackedChange('ti1', { p: 4, hpos: 10, i: 'brown ' }),
          makeTrackedChange('td2', { p: 14, hpos: 20, d: 'jumps ' }),
          makeTrackedChange('ti2', { p: 28, hpos: 40, i: 'dog' }),
        ]
      })

      it('does nothing if tracked changes have not changed', async function () {
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent, {
            changes: this.changes,
          }),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
      })

      it('adds new tracked changes', async function () {
        this.changes.splice(
          3,
          0,
          makeTrackedChange('td3', { p: 29, hpos: 35, d: 'lazy ' })
        )
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent, {
            changes: this.changes,
          }),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              {
                p: 35,
                r: 'lazy ',
                tracking: {
                  type: 'delete',
                  userId: USER_ID,
                  ts: TIMESTAMP,
                },
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('removes extra tracked changes', async function () {
        this.changes.splice(0, 1)
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent, {
            changes: this.changes,
          }),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              {
                p: 4,
                r: 'quick ',
                tracking: { type: 'none' },
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: {
                kind: 'history-resync',
              },
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('handles overlapping ranges', async function () {
        this.changes = [
          makeTrackedChange('ti1', { p: 0, i: 'the quic' }),
          makeTrackedChange('td1', { p: 8, d: 'k br' }),
          makeTrackedChange('ti2', { p: 14, hpos: 23, i: 'ps over' }),
        ]
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(this.persistedDoc, this.persistedDocContent, {
            changes: this.changes,
          }),
        ]
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )

        // Before: the [quick ][brown ] fox [jumps ]over the lazy dog
        // After:  [the quic][k br]own fox jum[ps over] the lazy dog
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              {
                p: 0,
                r: 'the quic',
                tracking: { type: 'insert', userId: USER_ID, ts: TIMESTAMP },
              },
              {
                p: 10,
                r: 'br',
                tracking: { type: 'delete', userId: USER_ID, ts: TIMESTAMP },
              },
              {
                p: 12,
                r: 'own ',
                tracking: { type: 'none' },
              },
              {
                p: 20,
                r: 'jum',
                tracking: { type: 'none' },
              },
              {
                p: 23,
                r: 'ps over',
                tracking: { type: 'insert', userId: USER_ID, ts: TIMESTAMP },
              },
              {
                p: 40,
                r: 'dog',
                tracking: { type: 'none' },
              },
            ],
            meta: {
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
            },
          },
        ])
      })

      it('adjusts tracked change positions when the underlying text has changed', async function () {
        const updates = [
          docContentSyncUpdate(
            this.persistedDoc,
            'every fox jumps over the lazy dog',
            {
              changes: [
                makeTrackedChange('ti1', { p: 5, i: ' ' }), // the space after every is still a tracked insert
                makeTrackedChange('td2', { p: 10, d: 'jumps ' }),
                makeTrackedChange('ti2', { p: 24, hpos: 30, i: 'dog' }),
              ],
            },
            this.resolvedCommentIds
          ),
        ]
        this.UpdateCompressor.diffAsShareJsOps.returns([
          { d: 'the quick brown', p: 0 },
          { i: 'every', p: 0 },
        ])
        const expandedUpdates =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.expandSyncUpdates(
            this.projectId,
            this.historyId,
            this.mostRecentChunk,
            updates,
            this.extendLock
          )
        expect(expandedUpdates).to.deep.equal([
          {
            doc: this.persistedDoc.doc,
            op: [
              { d: 'the quick brown', p: 0 },
              { i: 'every', p: 0 },
            ],
            meta: {
              pathname: this.persistedDoc.path,
              doc_length: this.persistedDocContent.length,
              resync: true,
              ts: TIMESTAMP,
              origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
            },
          },
        ])
      })
    })
  })

  describe('stuck sync state reproduction', function () {
    describe('when resyncDocContents has entries but no resyncDocContent update arrives', function () {
      beforeEach(function () {
        // Simulate the stuck state: project structure sync is done,
        // but doc content sync never completed for /main.tex
        const stuckSyncState = {
          resyncProjectStructure: false,
          resyncDocContents: ['/main.tex'],
          origin: { kind: 'history-resync' },
        }
        this.db.projectHistorySyncState.findOne.resolves(stuckSyncState)
      })

      it('should skip text updates for a doc stuck in resyncDocContents', async function () {
        const textUpdate = {
          doc: new ObjectId(),
          op: [{ i: 'hello', p: 0 }],
          meta: {
            pathname: '/main.tex',
            doc_length: 0,
          },
        }
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate.returns(false)
        this.UpdateTranslator.isTextUpdate.withArgs(textUpdate).returns(true)

        const { updates: filteredUpdates, syncState } =
          await this.SyncManager.promises.skipUpdatesDuringSync(
            this.projectId,
            [textUpdate]
          )

        // The text update is silently dropped — this is the stuck state bug
        expect(filteredUpdates).to.deep.equal([])
        // Sync state still shows /main.tex as syncing
        expect(syncState.toRaw().resyncDocContents).to.deep.equal(['/main.tex'])
        // Metric is emitted for the skipped update
        expect(
          this.Metrics.inc.calledWith('project_history_sync_update_skipped')
        ).to.be.true
      })
    })
  })
})